This article is an on-site model of our Moral Money e-newsletter. Sign up right here to get the e-newsletter despatched straight to your inbox.
Visit our Moral Money hub for all the most recent ESG information, opinion and evaluation from across the FT
To some — together with, it appears, the UK prime minister — recycling is a boring affair that consists largely of sorting family waste into variously colored bins. But the recycling of essential minerals, and of battery metals particularly, is changing into a significant geostrategic concern within the new vitality economic system — and some of the necessary clear tech sectors to look at within the subsequent few years.
That’s the main focus of at present’s e-newsletter, drawing on my journey to Norway to shoot a part of our forthcoming movie on the lithium provide chain.
Meanwhile, don’t overlook to register for the primary Moral Money Summit Africa, taking place in Johannesburg and on-line subsequent Tuesday, November 21. Moral Money e-newsletter subscribers can save 20 per cent on the in-person move, or register for the digital move without cost.
The ‘above-ground mines’ that might assist drive the electrical automobile revolution
Fredrikstad, a sleepy historic fort metropolis in southern Norway, shouldn’t be what most individuals would think about once they consider a mining city.
But that’s what it’s now in line with executives at Hydrovolt, which has constructed Europe’s largest battery recycling plant there.
“We are actually creating an above-ground mine . . . an alternative to traditional mining,” Andreas Frydensvang, Hydrovolt’s chief business officer, informed me throughout my current go to to the plant.
Hydrovolt is a three way partnership between Norsk Hydro, considered one of Europe’s largest aluminium producers, and Northvolt, the Swedish battery maker. Norway was a logical location for this primary plant as a result of it has the continent’s most mature electrical car market.
Since 2019, due to sturdy authorities incentives, the vast majority of automobiles bought in Norway have been electrical. That, over time, will translate into a gentle stream of used batteries that may be shredded and separated into their constituent metals — with Norsk Hydro getting the aluminium from the casing, and Northvolt taking the battery metals resembling lithium, nickel and cobalt.
Recycling has not at all times been seen as probably the most clearly thrilling space of unpolluted tech. But battery recycling, particularly, has emerged as an important ingredient of the scramble for vitality safety within the low-carbon vitality period.
The Critical Raw Materials Act proposed by the European Commission in March made clear the significance of this area. As the EU follows Norway’s lead by shifting to battery-powered automobiles, its demand for battery metals will rise dramatically. The area’s personal mineral assets — regardless of some fascinating lithium mining initiatives in France, Portugal and England — will be capable of cowl solely a small fraction of its battery steel necessities. And in procuring Congolese cobalt or Indonesian nickel, it faces powerful competitors from the Chinese refiners and battery makers who presently dominate that offer chain.
So battery recycling might be an necessary supply of those minerals — one that may turn out to be more and more fruitful over the subsequent couple of a long time, because the move of used “end-of-life” automobile batteries grows.
The proposed EU legislation would mandate that home mining ought to cowl 10 per cent of the bloc’s consumption of “critical raw materials” (minerals judged essential to financial exercise, particularly across the vitality transition, and with a excessive threat of provide disruption). Meanwhile, 20 per cent, below the most recent model of the proposal, should come from recycling throughout the EU.
Battery metals recycling is a precedence for the US authorities, too. Under Joe Biden’s clear energy-focused Inflation Reduction Act, authorities incentives for procurement of domestically produced battery minerals apply to recycled in addition to newly mined metals — giving a helpful shot within the arm for this sector.
Among probably the most outstanding US battery recyclers is Redwood Materials, based by Tesla’s longtime chief know-how officer JB Straubel. Redwood has been one of many largest beneficiaries of the Biden administration’s clear tech push, securing a $2bn mortgage from the US Department of Energy.
Announcing that mortgage on a go to to Redwood’s recycling plant in Nevada, US vitality secretary Jennifer Granholm hailed the “outsized role” the corporate would play in “bringing the battery supply chain home”. “China might be starting to worry,” she added.
Given the present international steadiness of exercise and funding in battery recycling, that latter comment from Granholm seems a tad vainglorious. China accounts for 80-90 per cent of present battery recycling exercise, in line with Duo Fu, who leads battery markets analysis at Rystad Energy. And the dimensions of Chinese recycling funding dwarfs what is occurring within the west.
The largest battery recycling plant in North America, opened in March by start-up Ascend Elements in Georgia, has the capability to course of 30,000 tonnes of used batteries and battery manufacturing scrap per yr. Hydrovolt’s plant in Norway can deal with 12,000 tonnes a yr.
China’s largest, run by a subsidiary of battery large CATL, has a capability of 120,000 tonnes. Rystad’s newest report on the sector profiles 4 extra Chinese initiatives below building or growth of comparable or better scale, the most important of which may have a capability of 300,000 tonnes.
There are limits to what industrial coverage can do to redress this imbalance. Much of the US authorities’s help is being deployed by means of Jigar Shah, the previous clear tech investor who’s now tasked with deploying as much as $400bn in federal funds by means of the vitality division’s Loan Programs Office.
A current Wall Street Journal profile of Shah contained a telling anecdote about an alternate with Ajay Kochhar, chief government of Li-Cycle, some of the outstanding US battery recycling firms. Kochhar was uncertain about Shah’s supply of an enormous authorities mortgage, saying he was uncertain how shortly Li-Cycle might repay it. Shah informed Kochhar to not fear, and the 2 went on to agree a $375mn federal mortgage.
Subsequent developments have made Kochhar’s concern look prescient. Rising rates of interest and value inflation have hit Li-Cycle onerous, forcing it to pause building of a plant in New York state, and elevating questions on whether or not the nonetheless pending authorities mortgage can be issued. Li-Cycle’s share worth has fallen 84 per cent because it went public in late 2020.
The basic problem right here is round timing. In a decade or so, European and North American battery recyclers will begin getting the massive provides of used batteries that they should make a huge impact on the essential minerals provide chain. But within the meantime, warns Duo Fu, who leads battery markets analysis at Rystad, lots of them are in “cash-burning mode”.
Their Chinese counterparts are in a stronger place. China’s electrical automobile market is way more mature, due to in depth authorities coverage help courting again greater than a decade. That means Chinese recyclers are already getting a better provide of used automobile batteries. And as a result of China accounts for the lion’s share of battery manufacturing, additionally they get pleasure from a a lot stronger move of scrap supplies from present manufacturing.
Consumer driving habits are one other issue driving sooner recycling progress in China, Fu informed me. Chinese electrical automobile house owners have a tendency to make use of their automobiles way more intensively than western counterparts, which means their batteries are junked after eight to 10 years, slightly than 10 to fifteen in Europe and North America.
Back in Fredrikstad, Hydrovolt chief government Ole-Christen Enger burdened the strategic significance of guaranteeing “that the materials that we use in products here in Europe, stay in Europe, and that we recycle them into new products”. The newest coverage strikes from politicians in Brussels, and in Washington, recommend additionally they view this as a key technique of bolstering vitality safety.
But the brand new firms on this area have a tough highway forward, as they work to construct capability for a surge in exercise that’s nonetheless years away — amid a punishing monetary surroundings that has been pummelling firms throughout the clear tech area. If they’re to play their half in bolstering home vitality safety, they might want to guarantee they’ve the affected person capital they should get by means of the remainder of this decade.
The UN COP28 summit ought to “launch a global campaign to inform the public and rally political support” for local weather motion, argues former World Bank official Vinod Thomas.
Recommended newsletters for you
FT Asset Management — The inside story on the movers and shakers behind a multitrillion-dollar business. Sign up right here
Energy Source — Essential vitality information, evaluation and insider intelligence. Sign up right here