Trying Simple Ina Garten Steak Recipe, Family Loved It: Review | Invesloan.com

As a busy mom, I’m a big fan of recipes that are big on flavor but short on ingredients. Luckily, the ingredients for Garten’s New York strip steaks were simple to find.

I started by picking up three 1½-inch-thick New York strip steaks at the grocery store, and was pleased to find I already had the rest of the ingredients in my pantry.

Along with the steaks, I pulled out salt and pepper, 2 teaspoons of light brown sugar, 2 teaspoons of ground coffee, a teaspoon each of garlic powder, chipotle-chile powder, and crushed red pepper flakes, and 1½ tablespoons of olive oil.

The first thing I did was mix up the rub — a blend of coffee, chipotle-chile powder, sugar, garlic, and crushed red pepper flakes.

Once the ingredients were combined, I slathered each steak with olive oil and massaged the rub into both sides of the meat, making sure to coat the edges of each piece.

In her recipe, Garten suggests allowing the rub to sit on the steaks for at least two hours.

Since I had lots of time, I made the rub and put it on the meat in the morning. I then covered the steaks with plastic wrap and put them in the refrigerator for about eight hours.

This steak recipe was all about the grilling method. Garten stressed the importance of having an accurate timer to make sure they were cooked perfectly.

I heated enough charcoal to fill half of my grill, leaving the opposite side empty.

I cooked all three steaks together over the hot charcoal, starting with exactly two minutes on one side. Then, I flipped the meat and cooked it on the opposite side for two minutes.

From there, the steaks were removed from the heat and moved to the empty side of the grill.

I put the lid on the grill and opened the vent, per Garten’s instructions, then allowed the steaks to sit on the cool portion for eight more minutes.

After the steaks had reached a medium temperature, I removed them from the charcoal grill and brought them inside to rest for 15 minutes.

The steaks looked beautiful, coated with charcoal grill marks and crispy spices, and the savory smell of freshly grilled steak filled my kitchen.

Even my 10-year-old dog was enthralled by the smell. Throughout the resting and slicing process, he peaked around the corners of the kitchen in hopes of getting a bite.

Slicing into these perfectly grilled steaks was easy, and the meat separated and fell apart like pats of butter. The fat in the New York strip steaks was soft and caramelized, and the meat was perfectly pink.

Three New York strips is a lot of meat, and we knew we’d have plenty of leftovers to use the following night in steak fajitas — a win in our book.

In the future, to keep costs low, I’d probably buy half as much steak (ours weighed in at over 2 pounds) for our family of four. Still, this meal in its full measurements would be an impressive recipe to grill next time we’re entertaining guests for dinner.

At Garten’s suggestion, I finished the sliced steak off with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt and some freshly cracked black pepper.

The steak tasted slightly sweet from the brown sugar in the rub and had the perfect amount of savory pepperiness from the chile powder, coffee, and garlic.

The meat was melt-in-your-mouth perfect, with soft, buttery fat and a seasoned, charred outside that felt like a burst of flavor in each bite.

Like every other Ina Garten recipe I’ve tried, the New York strip steaks were a hit with everyone in my family.

Not only was it low on ingredients and fairly simple to put together and execute, but the result was some of the most perfectly-grilled, tender steaks I’ve ever made

I would definitely use Garten’s grilling method again for other cuts of steak as well.

Knowing I have this foolproof cooking method in my arsenal will make me more inclined to splurge on expensive cuts of steak since, like Garten, I now know how to cook them without messing them up.

This story was originally published on October 10, 2024, and most recently updated on May 20, 2025.