Giving out free coffee might not sound like a winning business strategy.
For Brandon Sardi, the founder of San Francisco-based Poorboy Coffee, it became a way to market his company and put money in another entrepreneur’s pocket.
Poorboy started with pop-ups at wine bars. Sardi did hundreds of them during the company’s first couple of years, but the business model was tough to justify: He and his team would spend hours preparing, hauling equipment, setting up, and hoping enough people would stop by for a $5 drink.
Then Poorboy moved into private catering, where clients pay in advance. The economics were better, Sardi said, and he largely stopped doing public pop-ups — but he missed the community-facing side of the business.
That’s where “Who Gives a Hand” comes in: a new pay-what-you-want pop-up series. Customers can take a drink for free or contribute whatever amount they choose. Every dollar collected is passed directly to another local small business.
“It’s a way for us to be creative as far as marketing goes,” Sardi told Business Insider. “I want people to hear more about Poorboy, and especially in a good light.”
Customers paid more than expected at the first pop-up
Sardi held the first Who Gives a Hand event at a former Poorboy pop-up location. He expected the prospect of free drinks, combined with promotion on social media, to draw a crowd.
He was surprised when no line formed.
The event was slow — a familiar feeling from Poorboy’s earlier pop-up days — but the customers who did show up were generous. Sardi said nearly everyone contributed, with some paying more than they would have for a typical drink and others giving as much as $50.
Want more Business Insider in your news feed?
Add BI in Google so our reporting is easier to find when you’re searching for what matters.
He set up a live tracker showing the total, which helped entice people to add to the pot.
Over three hours, the event collected $957 in pay-it-forward contributions — more than double the roughly $450 in sales he said a typical pop-up brought in. Sardi passed the money on to the owners of AK Meats, a family-run San Francisco business.
The model isn’t foolproof
The second event produced a different result.
Although roughly as many people stopped by, more took their drinks without paying — which Sardi said was completely within the spirit of the model.
He suspects some customers didn’t fully understand the concept, but the experience didn’t discourage him. Sardi is planning more pop-ups, including one in New York City.
While not as successful as the first, the second event still collected about $500. Sardi’s staff declined payment for their time, wanting to contribute to the pay-it-forward effort themselves. Sardi added another $500 of his own money so Poorboy could again pass $1,000 along to another local business.
There are real costs to staging the events: ingredients, transportation, staff time, and a full day of work.
Still, he sees the exchange as worthwhile.
Customers get a good coffee and the freedom to decide what it’s worth. Poorboy gets an opportunity to introduce itself to potential customers and build goodwill. And a local small business receives a no-strings-attached cash infusion.
“It’s kind of like a win-win-win in every sense,” he said.
For Sardi, who started Poorboy with about $500, the final piece matters most. He knows how difficult it can be to bootstrap an idea and hopes the gesture can help another owner keep going.
“To be able to, after the pop-up, give that chunk of change to someone and make someone’s day and see their reaction,” he said, “it’s kind of priceless.”


