I was absolutely thrilled when my oldest child got her first retail job. Within a few weeks of starting, she was sometimes working 20 or more hours a week, bringing home a solid paycheck at just 17.
However, I quickly realized how little I’d taught her about money management. Judging by the number of Amazon packages arriving on our porch, addressed to my daughter, I knew we still have a lot of work to do, but I wanted to be careful in the way I guided her.
We tried to talk about money early
When our four kids were young, we used a jar system for their allowances. They would divide their singles and fives among the jars, which included one for savings. Then, they would place their spending money in their wallets. This system was simple and it worked for a time. When they received money for their birthdays or Christmas, we would deposit those funds into their savings accounts to instill the idea of saving for future expenses or for a rainy day.
I guess time got away from me. In the blink of an eye, my sweet elementary school girl who spent her days creating art and dancing is now approaching high school graduation. With her sudden and bountiful-for-her-age income, it was time for a crash course in budgeting.
Courtesy of Rachel Garlinghouse.
We had to decide how we would handle her new income
My husband and I suddenly had so many decisions to make. What should our daughter’s financial responsibilities be at this age? Which essentials and wants should we continue to pay for? How much should she place in her savings account versus how much of her check should she be able to freely spend?
I decided that I wanted my daughter to learn through trial and error, with support.
There were times I cringed when I saw another Amazon order arrive on our doorstep, the package addressed to my daughter, or I knew she’d decided to get Starbucks for herself and treat her friend who wasn’t working. But, isn’t it ok to enjoy the fruits of her labor? I felt as if I were in one of those old school cartoons, an angel on one shoulder and a devil on the other. As a parent, I wasn’t sure what I was supposed to be teaching her.
She’s learning that money flow is dynamic
She’s been at her job for almost six months now. Her hours wane and increase based on the store’s busy and slow seasons. She’s had large paychecks, as well as paychecks for only a few hours of work. Learning to adjust with every pay cycle has been challenging. As a parent, I know my job isn’t to fix my child’s feelings that naturally come with every challenge. Rather, my job is to hold space for frustration and encourage her to process and problem-solve.
What I’ve found is that there is no end-all, be-all guidebook to teaching our kids about money. Every family dynamic and financial situation is different and ever-changing. I personally value having healthy food at home over eating out, I like buying quality clothing at a deep discount, and I am not one to do much extra for myself, like get my nails done. My values, however, don’t have to be my child’s — not now or even in the future.
Instead, I want her to have basic financial competency and confidence. I also want her to understand the value of a dollar, which is why she now has to pay some of her own expenses, such as any eating out at coffee shop, as well as her favorite press-on nails, or (yet another) stainless steel water bottle that she just has to have. We also charge her $10 (much less than an Uber would cost) for a roundtrip ride to and from work, preparing her for putting gas in her own vehicle in the near future.
She has opted to save around 75% of each paycheck, no matter how many hours she worked that week. That was her choice, and her father and I are pleased with it. She is slowly learning to spend wisely, to pause and ask herself, “Do I really want this beyond just this moment?“ She is truly living and learning — and so are we.
